HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo

Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
February 1, 2024
Vol. 81
No. 5
Reader's Guide

What Do Students Need to Be Well?

author avatar

    premium resources logo

    Premium Resource

    Social-emotional learning
    What Do Students Need to Be Well? Header Image
    Credit: Jacob Lund / Shutterstock
      Wednesday morning, first period. A student erupts in the middle of class. “I want to die,” the 8th grader yells, within earshot of their peers. A paraeducator covers the class while the teacher walks the student down to the counseling office. A team of administrators documents the incident, does a suicide risk assessment, and writes a crisis center referral. The student’s parents soon come to pick them up. 
      A short time later at the same school, a teacher leads an SEL lesson about mental health. By the end of it, a student shuts down. She plants herself on the classroom floor, covers her face with her hair, and goes silent. The bell rings, and her classmates file out of the room. A counselor spends the next 30 minutes trying to convince the student to come to the counseling office. Once there, she admits to self-harming at home. She says it would be better if she weren’t alive. Another risk assessment, another crisis center referral.  
      Lunchtime is almost over when a 6th grader’s ex-boyfriend airdrops explicit photos of her to other kids in the cafeteria. Administrators intervene; because both kids are minors, they call the non-emergency police. The girl is embarrassed and panicking.  
      Toward the end of the day, a school security officer stops a girl in the hall for suspected vaping. When her mother comes to the school, she reveals texts she found between her daughter and another student about meeting in the school bathroom to exchange drugs. The police and the other student’s parents are called, and another referral—this time to a crisis center for substance abuse—is written. 
      All days don’t look like this, a staff member at the school shared with me, but enough are starting to resemble it to make it seem fairly routine. As U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy says, the challenges today’s youth face are “unprecedented” and inevitably make their way into schools.  
      Research shows that mental health impacts nearly every aspect of teaching and learning. Depression and anxiety, for example, have been linked to lower attendance, poor academic performance, and reduced ­concentration. As this issue of ­Educational Leadership emphasizes, schools have a crucial role to play both in terms of preventative work and trauma-informed practice.

      Mental health impacts nearly every aspect of teaching and learning.

      Author Image

      One key protective factor, several articles note, is strong relationships—connecting each student with a trusted adult with whom they can confide. In the school highlighted here, the positive rapport staff had built prior to that day was essential to de-escalating those incidences and connecting families with additional support. This year, the school brought in a social worker who provides direct therapeutic services to a small caseload of students. 
      When they make intentional ­connections, educators can better recognize when something seems off. If a student shows major behavior changes, like sudden withdrawal, as The Jed Foundation’s Tony Walker notes, “there’s reason for concern.” Educators aren’t expected to be therapists, but they can be the right person at the right time. 
      Schools can also reduce stressors that unnecessarily add to students’ cognitive load, says assessment expert Cathy Vatterott. For example, allowing do-overs, extending passing time between classes, and not grading homework can ease some of the anxiety students feel in school. So can “digital detoxes” and more predictability in school routines
      As articles in this issue show, mental health matters for student learning and success. Helping students be welland find joy—requires attentiveness, intentional structures, and compassion.

      Reflect & Discuss

      "The Second Backpack: Creating Predictable Systems for Students with Trauma" by Theresa Melito-Conners

      ➛ Has your school codified a systemwide response to student trauma?

      ➛ What trauma-inducing triggers have you observed in your own school or classroom?

      ➛ How predictable are your school and classroom routines? What could you do to make them more predictable?

      "4 Pillars of School Mental Health" by Juan-Diego Estrada and Stephen Popp

      ➛ When your school hosts health-related activities, like “wellness fairs” or workshops, does content focus on caring for mental health as much as physical health?

      ➛ Consider the idea of being an “emotion scientist” versus an “emotion judge.” Might an “emotion scientist” approach change how certain students’ behavior affects you?

      ➛ How could you talk with students about being an emotion scientist vs. emotion judge—and what might result if you did?

      "Let’s Stop Shaming Teens About Social Media Use" by Candice L. Odgers and Gillian R. Hayes

      ➛ Do you have negative feelings toward teen social media use? Did this article change any of those perceptions?

      ➛ Do you talk to your students about social media or incorporate it into your teaching in any way? Why or why not?

      ➛ How do you see student autonomy as contributing to improved student mental health?

      ➛ What practices or policies has your school initiated to reduce student stress?

      ➛ Do you give students leeway in designing their own learning?

      Sarah McKibben is the editor in chief of Educational Leadership magazine.

      Learn More

      ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

      Let us help you put your vision into action.
      Related Articles
      View all
      undefined
      Social-emotional learning
      The Power of Educator EQ
      Brooke Stafford-Brizard
      7 months ago

      undefined
      Purposeful Work: A Calling or a Siren’s Song?
      Chase Mielke
      7 months ago

      undefined
      The Value of “Expressive Flexibility”
      Kate Stoltzfus
      7 months ago

      undefined
      The Power of “Habits of Mind” to Increase Emotional Awareness
      Arthur L. Costa & Bena Kallick et al.
      7 months ago

      undefined
      EI: A Bedrock of Thriving Schools
      Sarah McKibben
      7 months ago
      Related Articles
      The Power of Educator EQ
      Brooke Stafford-Brizard
      7 months ago

      Purposeful Work: A Calling or a Siren’s Song?
      Chase Mielke
      7 months ago

      The Value of “Expressive Flexibility”
      Kate Stoltzfus
      7 months ago

      The Power of “Habits of Mind” to Increase Emotional Awareness
      Arthur L. Costa & Bena Kallick et al.
      7 months ago

      EI: A Bedrock of Thriving Schools
      Sarah McKibben
      7 months ago
      From our issue
      February 2024 Header Image
      Mental Health Matters
      Go To Publication